Manchester United defender Harry Maguire has sparked debate by advocating for a significant reduction in the use of VAR, proposing it be restricted to offside decisions only. His remarks come amid growing dissatisfaction with the system, which he claims remains “opinion-based” and divisive.
VAR Controversy: The Current Debate
VAR, or Video Assistant Referee, has been a controversial addition to football since its implementation five years ago. Intended to reduce errors, it has instead been criticized for its subjectivity in decisions regarding penalties, red cards, and handballs. Maguire believes these opinion-based calls should not be under VAR’s jurisdiction.
Wolves’ Proposal and the Upcoming Vote
Next month, Premier League clubs will vote on a proposal from Wolverhampton Wanderers to scrap VAR entirely. However, the proposal faces significant challenges. The complexity and cost of removing VAR, especially for clubs that have invested heavily in its implementation, make it unlikely to succeed.
Player and Club Reactions
Several former Premier League players have voiced their desire to eliminate VAR. Newcastle’s Anthony Gordon recently stated, “get rid of it or get better,” after a contentious penalty decision. Despite these calls, Maguire is the first current player to publicly advocate for limiting VAR’s scope.
Maguire’s Stance on VAR
Maguire’s position is clear: he supports VAR only for offside decisions. “Offsides are factual and not subjective,” he argues. “It is so difficult to lose a game on an offside goal when a player is two or three yards offside. Everyone makes mistakes, linesmen make mistakes, so that is why I would keep VAR for that.”
He acknowledges that his stance may divide opinion but insists that reducing VAR’s remit would reduce controversy. “People disagree on decisions even with VAR, so it’s better to keep it for clear-cut, factual decisions like offsides.”
Potential Improvements and Future of VAR
Despite the push to scrap VAR, the Premier League is likely to enhance the system rather than abandon it. Automated offside technology is expected next season, promising quicker and more accurate decisions. This innovation aims to address one of the major criticisms of VAR: the long waiting times for decisions.
Moreover, the Premier League is considering better in-stadium communication to improve the experience for fans. Currently, spectators in the stadium are often left in the dark during VAR reviews, unlike TV viewers who see the decision-making process.
Challenges to Scrapping VAR
One significant barrier to eliminating VAR is the inconsistency it would create, especially for Premier League teams competing in European competitions, where VAR is used. Clubs are also concerned about the financial implications, particularly for those with lower budgets who have already invested heavily in VAR infrastructure.
Conclusion: The Future of VAR
As the Premier League clubs prepare to vote, it is evident that while there is dissatisfaction with VAR, completely scrapping it is unlikely. Instead, improvements such as automated offsides and better communication with fans are expected to address some of the current issues.
Maguire’s call to limit VAR to offsides reflects a broader desire for clarity and consistency in football officiating. Whether his suggestions will be adopted remains to be seen, but the debate underscores the need for ongoing evaluation and enhancement of the VAR system to better serve the game.
Read also: Manchester United in Turmoil: Uncertainty Surrounds Bruno Fernandes Amid INEOS Takeover